“Take immediate action to improve the road layout” – an open letter by Deep Lee’s boyfriend

Kenji Hirasawa is the boyfriend of Deep Lee, who was killed by a lorry cycling at King’s Cross on 3rd October, 2011. Kenji, who gave a poignant interview to the “Camden New Journal”, wrote an open letter to Camden’s Culture & Environment Scrutiny Committee and gave me the permission to publish it on the blog.
Deep Lee's memorial bike at King's Cross

Here’s what Kenji’s wrote:

“My girlfriend Deep Lee (Min Joo Lee) was killed in a car accident at the junction of York Way and Gray’s Inn Road on 3rd of October, 2011.  I have submitted this email as I would like the council to consider this junction as extremely dangerous for cyclists and consequently needs some immediate improvements made to protect local residents to prevent a similar accident happening again.

The issue with the road where my girlfriend was killed by the lorry is that there is no cycle lane and the road is too narrow to share the space with both cars and cyclists. Therefore cyclists are forced to be extremely close to vehicles and it is difficult for them to be seen from large trucks.

My girlfriend was just in front of the truck and both her and the truck driver were waiting for the traffic signal to change.
The driver of the truck might not have been able to see her directly and he appeared not to have looked forward using
the mirror which is placed to see just in front of the car around bumper. Consequently Deep was run over.

I would like the Council to consider making the road safer and implementing changes such as providing cycle lanes like those used in the Netherlands or making selected roads safer for cyclists and informing cyclists to use these roads.

With the number of cyclists on the roads increasing all the time (and with the college of Central Saint Martins, where Deep attended) recently having moved to King’s Cross, I am keen to prevent similar accidents happening again in the future.
This, combined with an increased number of trucks being used to construct the Olympics sites and prepare London for the games makes the risk all the greater.

I would like to urge the council to take some immediate action to improve the road layout for cyclists before more accidents happen and more cyclists are killed.

Your sincerely,

Kenji Hirasawa”

The junction where Deep Lee died has been heavily criticised by road safety experts and local pedestrian and cycling campaigners for years.  A 2008 report commissioned by TfL came to the conclusion that the whole area was highly dangerous and should be re-designed.

However, TfL did not heed that advice. Smoothing the traffic flow for motorised vehicles was deemed more important than the life of cyclists.

In an appalling statement, this was blithely acknowledged by a representative of Transport for London admitted in a hearing at Camden Town hall, as the Camden New Journal reported:

A TfL representative insisted that introducing a cycle lane at the junction would “cause considerable queues”, stressing that there was “limited time” to conduct a review of the proposed changes for the junction because of a “commitment” to make them in time for the Olympic Games.

Early next year, TfL plans to make some changes at the junction. However, they do not address the fundamental issues at all. James Thomas, the maker of the memorial bike for Deep Lee, had a close look at the plans and concludes that there are

“no improvements in safety for cyclists.”

This is where Deep Lee died - TfL plans no changes to the junction (drawing by James Thomas)

In an email to TfL, James wrote:

” Your proposals at that junction in the direction [Deep Lee] was travelling, amount to a decision to repaint the existing cycling box!

This completely ignores the problem that there are two lanes of traffic, including many HGV vehicles, entering that junction from Grays Inn road. At that junction the road narrows, so vehicles jostle for position and they also turn through 45 degrees, with the added distraction of many people crossing the road, cyclist end up being crushed under the wheels of HGVs.

That is what happened to Deep Lee.

In 2012 and foreward there will be many more pedestrians crossing the street, more and more cyclists and HGVs servicing the Kings Cross site for another 5+ years.

I warn you that the likely consequence is that more cyclists will be killed. If that is the case and with TFL ignoring their own study into the junction from 3 years ago, which suggested that real safety improvements should be made, then I believe TFL and the mayor are being negligent in ignoring this issue and should be wary of the case of corporate manslaughter that has already been suggested.”

Madras Place is still dangerous

Junction of Madras Place and Holloway Road: New design, old problems

It has been a long and tedious campaign. Pedestrian and cycling campaigners pressured Transport for London for several years to redesign an important crossing of Holloway Road in Islington that was inherently unsafe for pedestrians and cyclists. In 2008, Lisa Pontecorvo was killed by a lorry while wheeling her cycle across the busy street. One year later, a pedestrian was knocked down at the same junction.

After several months of construction work, the new junction was finally opened to traffic several days ago. On their website, Islington Cyclist Action Group (disclaimer: I’m a mostly passive member of them but was not involved in the campaign because I moved to London only later) hails the redesign as

“an unalloyed success story for local campaigners working with Islington council officers and Transport for London (TfL)”

Unfortunately, however, I have to play the party pooper.

I use the junction on a daily basis and am rather dissappointed by the new road layout. It’s is better than the original design, but it still is far from perfect and continuous to be inherently dangerous for cyclists.

The basic problem of the junction still has not been resolved by the redesign. The fundamental issue is related to north bound car traffic on Holloway road. There is way too much empty space  between the traffic lights for northbound cars and the crossing for cyclists.

In the peak hours, there are traffic jams on Holloway road. The typical situation, depicted in the picture above, is this: Northbound cars pass green traffic lights but cannot clear the junction due to congestion. Cars queuing in the junction do not realise when the lights change to red for cars and cyclists get a green light. Quite often, in such a moment the car traffic on Holloway road clears slightly and the cars blocking the junction move on. They are on a direct collision course with the cyclists who face a green light at that point of time.

(Update: When I wrote this post I  wasn’t aware that there now is a second light for cars about 20 meters further north that prevents the clearing of the northboung car traffic while cyclists face a green light. This, apparently, prevents that the traffic blocking the junction clears while cyclists face a green light.  Hence, my initial headline [“Death by design”] appears to be slightly over the top. This is why I removed it.)

The redesign of the junction tried to address this problem but fails to solve it. Nowadays, there is a clearly marked green cycle path across Holloway road and massive “Keep Clear” signs on the street in front of it. Additionally, the space between the lights for cars and the crossing for cyclists has been made smaller (the lights for cars were move a few yards north).

However, despite these measures, Madras Place is still a recipe for disaster. The photo, which I took this morning, shows a typical situation at Madras Place: Cyclists have a green light, but cars queue into the junction. Imagine that the skip lorry moves on – the car will follow suit and conflicts – possibly crashes – with cyclists are bound to occur.

From my point of view, the only permanent solution would be a second, additional traffic light for cars directly in front of the junction so drivers clearly understand that they have to wait while cyclists face a green light.

Otherwise, new accidents at Madras Place are just a matter of time.

At the moment, cyclists still are being confronted with unnecessary dangers at Madras Place and have to take extra care. Use your bell when facing a situation like the rider on the photo and do not ever cross Holloway Road in front of a HGV (you’re in the blindspot of the driver directly in front of a lorry – the driver can’t see you!)

Update: James Candlin just send me the following via the ICAG newsgroup:

Dear Olaf,

I have always said (on this forum and elsewhere) that the only modification which is actually needed is the one which distinguishes North side of the junction from South.

On the north side there is no central suspended traffic light and no repeater traffic light  either side where there is one on the South side.

This means any driver heading north in traffic who gets stopped beyond the stop line does not know that the light has turned red for him and carries on as soon as the road clears regardless of the cyclists whom (as ever ) he ignores until too late.

The expensive rejig was wholly avoidable if they had just fitted the lamp on the post which is actually there for the purpose. They could add to the safety by putting up a reminder notice of the cycle lane for motorists or  a yellow box  junction. Why not put this in your blog too.

Regards James Candlin

Update II: Apparently, TfL already is aware of the remaining problems at the junction. A few days before I wrote this post they met with cycling and pedestrian campaigners and discussed further improvements. Let’s see how things pan out.

TfL, listen to the riders please – The cycling nightmare that King’s Cross is

Pictured above it the ghost bike at King’s Cross, installed for Min Joo Lee – called Deep Lee by her friends , 24, who was killed by a lorry on the junction of Euston Road and York Way on 3 October. According to her friends, she was a very experienced cyclist and “always careful and aware”.

For years, pedestrian and cycling campaigners have severely criticised the road design around King’s Cross. A 2008 report commissioned by TfL came to the conclusion that the whole area was highly dangerous and should be re-designed. I’ve written several times about the danger in the area  – the first post was six months before Deep Lee’s death.

A number of cyclists have shared their experiences in comments on this blog. All agree that the area is a complete nightmare for cyclists.

I think those views deserve more attention. Hence, I chose to document them in a separate post.

And, of course, I’d appreciate if more cyclists shared their views about the road design around King’s Cross. Write in the comments, please, I’ll add it to this post.

Ben Jarman says:

The entire junction is a deathtrap. Having been forced to use it in 2004 and 2005, when it was on my route to work, I now avoid it whenever possible, and will take a detour of a mile or more to do so.

This is after I was nearly crushed by a bendy bus in (I think) 2005; having dismounted to point out to the driver his lack of care, he got out of his cab and shoved and shouted at me. This case was sorted by a complaint to TfL, and the driver was disciplined, but it says something for the atmosphere created by a supremely badly-designed junction, possibly the most aggravating in London.

There is not enough space and cyclists are extremely vulnerable to other vehicles, a fact that anyone who has cycled there can see immediately. The fact that it is taking a human toll in terms of deaths for this to attract attention is a sad indictment of TfL’s priorities.

I am surprised to read over the last few days about the suppression of the report that was critical of this junction. Let’s hope it won’t take a further tragedy before TfL get off their dots and try to do something about this.

Shreds:

Construction traffic [around King’s Cross] is lethal. Whether it is because of the fact that they are paid by the lorry load or whether it is because the drivers are neanderthals or both, means they should not be on the roads at all. They are violent and aggressive drivers and will threaten anyone who dares to question that. Same around the Blackwall Tunnel.

 NCS

That junction [Euston Road/ York Way] is a nightmare, I have the privilege of it using everyday..along Euston Road, then up York Way, skimming along the white line of the bus lane whist trying not to get run over by motorised traffic hearing past at way faster than 30 miles an hour, not indicating etc. Continue reading “TfL, listen to the riders please – The cycling nightmare that King’s Cross is”

Let’s never forget her – the ghost bike for Deep Lee

The ghost bike for Deep Lee

Tonight at 6.30pm, about 60 people gathered on a narrow pedestrian island at King’s Cross, central London. Surrounded by horrific traffic – I was really afraid that somebody might get hit by a car – we all commemorated Deep Lee (Min Joo Lee), the 24 year old cyclist who died at this spot three weeks ago after she was hit by a lorry.

James Thomas, who build the bike (left) , and a good friend of Deep Lee (right)

Deep Lee’s best friend gave a very moving speech. It was a poignant and sad ceremony that gave me the shivers.  I hope that the bike will work as a reminder for all road users to respect each other and take care. It might also wake up Transport for London that a human-friendly redesign of the roads in the area is urgently needed.

Many thanks again to James Thomas, a cyclist working a few hundered yards away and to Beth (I don’t know her last name) James organised the bike and painted it. Beth, a designer, worked on the sign.

James explained his motivation in an interview with Will Perrin that is available here. I was happy that I could help with spreading the word. The whole initiative was organised informally by people over the internet who did not know each other. (Big society, here we come!) I’m really impressed by this amazing civic spirit.

On 3 November, there will be a memorial service at On 3 November, there will also memorial ceremony for her at the university. It starts at 6pm at Central Saint Martins College of Arts and Design ( Granary Building, 1 Granary Square London N1C 4AA)

Here’s a blog post by Mark on “I bike London” on the installation of the bikeMore of my photos from tonight are available here.

The “Camden New Journal” and the “Evening Standard” reported about the event. James produced this brief video about the work on the bike:

Corporate Manslaughter – is TfL a serial offender?

Unfortunately, this is how London streets looks only once a year. (Photo: ProfDEH via Wikipedia)

On Monday, 24 October the 14th London cyclist of the year was killed in traffic. A male rider was crushed by a tipper lorry in a roundabout near the Bow flyover in east London.

The media focuses on the fact that it was the first fatality on a so called “cycling superhighway”.

However, another fact is even more annoying and depressing.

Once again, there have been advance warnings to TfL about the the poor design of the junction where the crash happened.

As Wharf.co.uk reported yesterday:

“London Assembly Member John Biggs said he twice met with Transport for London officials over concerns with the Bow Flyover.

However, he was told there was no obvious solution which would not cause massive traffic delays. Mr Biggs said he had the same response in a written question to London Mayor Boris Johnson.”

(Diamond Geezer discusses the awful road layout at the Bow Flyover in detail here.)

This is at least the forth time this year that a London cyclist died on a road that was harshly criticised in advance. Continue reading “Corporate Manslaughter – is TfL a serial offender?”

A Ghost bike for Deep Lee (Min Joo Lee)

A Ghost Bike in Berlin (Photo by Bukk via Wikipedia)

Over the weekend, James Thomas (on Twitter, he’s @jamesWPThomas) has been working on the ghost bike for Min Joo Lee, who was called Deep Lee by her friends.  She was killed there on 3 October by a lorry while she was cycling to St. Martins College at King’s Cross.

He’s going to install the bike at the junction Euston Road / York Way this Wednesday (26 October) at 6.30pm.

I’m really grateful that James took the initiative and think the installation of the bike could be a good opportunity to remember Min Joo Lee.

I’d really appreaciate if her friends and fellow cyclists showed up next Wednesday to commemorate the tragic death of Min Joo Lee.

I’ll be there and bring some flowers.

Update: On 3 November, there will also memorial ceremony for her at the university. It starts at 6pm at Central Saint Martins College of Arts and Design (Granary Building, 1 Granary Square London N1C 4AA)

Update II: Today, I walked over to meet James Thomas personally for the first time and had a chat with him. Here’s a photo of James (right) and Adrian Wiehahn working on the bike in his lunch break.

 

A human friendly version of Blackfriars Bridge

Blackfriars Bridge has rightly become a symbol for car-centric planning in London and the utter disregard of Transport for London and Boris Johnson for the real needs of cyclists in London.

The redesign of the bridge and the planned increase of the speed limit for cars from 20 to 30 mph has been annoying cyclists for months. This comes despite the fact that two cyclists died on the Bridge in recent years and many more were injured by cars.

Human-friendly version of Blackfriars Bridge.

Two days before the next demonstration is going to happen – another “flashride” on 12 October, 6pmLondon Cycling Campaign has  revealed an alternative proposal for the road layout of the bridge.

From LCC’s press release:

Urban planner Richard Lewis, who led LCC’s design team, said, “Our layout is based on continental principles, which eliminate junction conflicts that put cyclists at risk.”

LCC chief executive Ashok Sinha said, “Our visionary design provides larger and better spaces for people on bikes and on foot, but also retains bus and vehicle lanes.

“We hope these graphics stimulate debate among cyclists, pedestrians and city planners, so together we can come up with a solution that’s fit for all Londoners.

“Our city deserves to be a global leader in sustainable transport and liveable public spaces, not an also-ran.”

From my point of view, LCC’s proposal appears very sensible. If you share this impression, please join the flash ride next Wednesday (riders meet outside Doggetts pub at 5.45pm).